XXHighEnd - The Ultra HighEnd Audio Player
March 19, 2024, 10:50:38 am *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: August 6, 2017 : Phasure Webshop open ! Go to the Shop
Search current board structure only !!  
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 [7] 8 9 10
 61 
 on: August 16, 2023, 02:07:27 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by PeterSt
Something is seriously wrong, and possibly Tidal doesn't know that themselves.

First a conclusion of what's below, because I don't think I knew this : it should be so that the Tidal MQA presentation always was done on the fly. Read : during the playback (download if you will) the album is processed and turned into MQA. This should be derived from the "fact" that the Album ID stayed the same (see below) while today no 24 bit file comes from it. You will believe me when I say that the bottom version was denoted Max.

It may be less easy to grasp that the original MQA album was 24/96, but see below to proved that (2nd picture).

So one hour or so further and I have not been able to find even one album that would be Hires, so what remains is the proof that the Tidal app plays them as Hires. So let's see how we do that ...
Well, no clue. I guess this starts with not being able to play anyway because of (a Tidal message) "There's a network issue - unable to play".
Oh well.

An intermittent other conclusion seems to be that with the one album showing Max and the other showing nothing (= "Lossless") both are always 16/44.1 for those cases I examined and this includes existing ones on my HDD which are 24/48 at the file level. I have no clue / hint about whether these albums now are album-originals (CD's) or that now all flaws over at Tidal's and that Album ID's have been mixed up or what not.

If someone is able to verify the playback rate of the Stevie Wonder album (see in the first picture below) by Tidal app means, please don't hesitate. This should not be done by something like Roon, because that will upsample by default, once it detects MQA (and that tag sure is still in there - it now implies the Max tag).

I suppose it is very well possible that all is now tweaked such, that all prior MQA playback now thinks it is Hires. Why ? well, because
a. It was MQA's prescription for a few years already that upsampling should be done 2x by standard (I just did not comply to that with XXHighEnd);
b. I heard that MQA lights still lit, but that the blue/green led comes not on any more.

Ad b.: This would testify that officially MQA was shut off, but that we are fooled as much as we already were. Just by full automation. You can't see it on anything. Yea, with XXHighEnd ...
Or download the files and throw some knowledge at it (look at the file size - play through Foobar and *know* that it s*cks to begin with or else you'd be sure to do something wrong (while you are doing it right).

Pfff



 62 
 on: August 16, 2023, 01:06:10 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by PeterSt
Hey Colin,

Great thanks - I can work with that.
But bad news - as expected ...
It is 16/44.1 or IOW, the stupid MQA stuff (not even the "good" stuff, because 16 bits).

Internally it is denoted "HiRes" opposed to "Lossless" (smart move) and it readily explains why I deemed many albums flawed-sounding - this will sound bad as well (because molested Hires and nothing is done to it by XXHighEnd now (MQA decoding is disengaged per new download means).

Of course this depends on your info, although I can of course check that myself too. Wait ...
Hmm ... that says Master, so where did you find Max ? I verified the ID :
https://tidal.com/browse/album/4157739
hahahahahaha, bunch of stupid ***sholes. Look below;

So my Tidal player proposed an update and after that voilá, the Master denotation changed to Max.

As a bonus, the last picture shows nothing next to the albums while prior to the update more than half showed "Master" next to them.

So as expected, Tidal is fooling us all and I guess it won't be so that they saw that I can see through all (XXHighEnd can), and thus they banned XXHighEnd as a software player from Tidal. I do like to think this though. bye

Question is : how do all formal Tidal players work with this ? have they all been banned ?
How does the existing MQA hardware go about this ? The album is exactly the same as it was (you could do a compare, Colin) so that hardware (but also software players) will happily show it is still MQA.

In the end it is not the best example, because we should have a 24 bit one. But now I know how this works, I can inject those myself a. to the new environment and b. to the Tidal app.

More in a next post.

 63 
 on: August 16, 2023, 10:27:06 am 
Started by coliny - Last post by coliny
Hi Peter

Paul Simon/Your the One might tell you something.

Via Tidal App its Max & plays at 96KHz with & without MQA pass through so probably genuine HiRes (sounds great) Tidal #4157739.

Via Volumio it plays at 48/24 and marked as MQA (no decoding possible with volumio)

My download from XXHE from years ago also Tidal#4157739 is 44/24 and confirmes as MQA using the MqaTagRestorer.

Colin


 64 
 on: August 16, 2023, 06:27:03 am 
Started by coliny - Last post by PeterSt
Hi Colin and everyone,

A bit late with responding ...

I made good progress yesterday. The general consensus is that I was finally able to create an environment that allows comparison (meaning : all in good shape from within XXHighEnd). This now also allows to observe what "Max" does or does not.

Having said that, I don't even know yet how to recognize "Max" as such. This could be the most simple "look at the Sampling Rate, Peter !". Sure, but I like to have the examples first. When I have a couple - or know how to find them via the Tidal app - I can run the Spectrograph as usual (from within XXHighEnd). So if you have suspects, don't hesitate to post them here !
I think I told about it elsewhere, but if we have a new way of knowing how to observe certain data, it will be a matter of laying out the workflow as how I go about it myself at this moment. This means (for short cuts) that XXHighEnd can not search and integrally create the Library Area with Tidal albums as how we were used to, but they still will be there and, for example, show the latest (New) albums ready to play. Below an example of my New library (most people won't even know about the New feature as per last 2.11 super vague Release Notes), which just shows over my good old 2.11 Audio PC (Mach III in my case) without any bit of upgrade - put there yesterday. So the workflow is about how to create that in such a way that it is downwards compatible with all we have. And regardless of Max (which may or should work just the same), I have that now.

And for the best fun again : You can see it never stops and how I never get around with a new version, because now I finally have this going, it is Max which tempts again or a next new step first. I am also quite definite about something else (or actually not) : this Cloud stuff does not work out at all because a developer like me will always be behind the facts and things just stop working underway. I think elsewhere (in the realm of Tidal) I talked about how I killed the Amazon integration because of the very same, but already more than 10 years ago ... today this still happens. Tidal changes things, MQA comes about, MQA disappears, Tidal changes prior to that, and now Tidal changes again (with the Max thing, FWIW at this moment). The ERP environment (my main job) bugs me the very same. If the main tools are not "on premise" as how it is called, then it is up to the Gods how your company will survive the next month with the grilles (?) of the vendor(s) involved. I have *that* still all on premise, but it means that there can't be progress or else I have to do all myself within that shielded environment. Tidal is very similar, while they even cut me (XXHighEnd) off (say because I kept on going my own way, including not doing what MQA prescribed). In the end I will lose that - in the end all the customers will lose. But still not yet ...  Thank you !

Peter

 65 
 on: August 10, 2023, 04:31:17 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by coliny
Hi Peter

Appreciate all you say about Max.

I don't have any download option that enables me to examine the Spectrographs. Download is only possible at moment with android and you can't examine the file, its only possible to play them with the Tidal App. 3rd party apps never worked well for me and probably won't see Max files now.

I prefer sound quality from the W10 Tidal App over the Android App and that's with an up to date W10, possibly 14393.0 would be better but has to be online which might be risky.

Regards
Colin

 66 
 on: August 09, 2023, 12:17:05 am 
Started by coliny - Last post by PeterSt
At this moment all is too vague - and even worse than how it was with MQA alone. Probably this just *is* MQA as per reports that people's MQA DAC lits blue or green or whatever MQA colour.

Tidal itself is not to be trusted, like them just ditching software that can decode MQA which they or someone don't like ?

All 'n all I am waiting a little till the dust drops. But I will also try examples and see what comes from them technically, but also audibly.
Keep in mind that this is about the Spectrograph thing again and that you could do the same tests as you did (with so much efforts) before. If you only have that download means first (and I think you have that).

I am not sure yet how to approach this. I mean, if it would be decoded MQA, it should be possible to compare it to MQA-decoded files we decoded ourselves (IOW, the Unicode files again - you know about it all, Colin).

Notice that I don't/didn't trust the Max stuff from the start.

Best regards,
Peter

 67 
 on: August 05, 2023, 08:44:19 am 
Started by coliny - Last post by coliny
Tidal's Apps now include HiRes offerings, see attachment

Hires files are identified by a Max icon and these include MQA. Unless you measure output or have a DAC displaying Sample Rate you won't know exactly what you are getting.

I have Volumio for Tidal Streaming and it does not yet show Max files it still shows the M icon for MQA albums. Its probably the same for other 3rd party Tidal Streaming Apps.

For example Rufus Wainwright/Folkocracy:-

 via Volumio is still marked as M for MQA and plays at 48/24 (no MQA decoding with Volumio).

Streaming it with Tidal Android App it is marked Max and plays at 96/24 (I had MQA Pass Through enabled so I think its genuine HiRes).
 
Downloading and playing it with the Tidal Android App and it plays at 192/24 (possibly the App upsamples it).

Mission for Peter should he wish to accept it !!!

Colin


 68 
 on: July 23, 2023, 06:34:18 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by dsm

I have been working on something on and off, and it is in the stage of CoverArt not wanting to show.
When I see a minute, I am working on it.


That's great news Peter! I don't mind getting cover art in a different way as long as I can have access to Tidal again.

Best,

David



 69 
 on: July 22, 2023, 09:25:20 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by Tore
Peter, It was good to hear

Maybe Tidal_Jesse in that Reddit thread can help you?

https://twitter.com/JesseDorogusker

Tore

 70 
 on: July 22, 2023, 07:30:41 pm 
Started by coliny - Last post by PeterSt
Hi Tore,

I have been working on something on and off, and it is in the stage of CoverArt not wanting to show.
When I see a minute, I am working on it.

Regards,
Peter

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 [7] 8 9 10
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1 RC2 | SMF © 2001-2005, Lewis Media Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.17 seconds with 10 queries.