Two bit-identical files should sound identical when played back through XX. If they don't, then the only thing I can think of is that their location on the hard-drive matters.
Mani.
This is a conclusion I came up with awhile ago also. I'm glad that I have xxhe rip the files again to the main drive... somewhat consistent? but who knows... I've stopped listening too closely now that I've reached the ripe ol age of 52. I never compared ripping programs, but I'm glad I ripped the majority of my music using a plextor drive and their software. Now I use EAC with what I hope are good settings... also.... and I always felt it mattered... I rip the whole album to a single wav/cue file... ya, I still think it matters... even though peter splits em hehe as he rerips em to the C: drive. who knows... someones a little crazy
cookoo